The Fear That No One Would Notice If I Disappeared
From the editor: A reader wrote to us from abroad. She asked us to share her words anonymously. We are sharing them without changing a single thing, because we believe every woman who reads this will find something of herself inside it.
I have not said this to anyone. Not to the colleagues I eat lunch with on Tuesdays, who know the professional version of me, the competent one, the one who always has the right answer in meetings and laughs at the right moments in the corridor. Not to the friends I have made here over the years, good people, kind people, people I like genuinely and would help without hesitation, who nevertheless do not know me the way you know a person when you have grown up alongside them, when you have watched each other become, when you share a history that goes all the way down.
I have not said it because there is no way to say it that does not sound like something requiring an intervention. No way to drop it into conversation without the other person’s face shifting into concern and their voice changing register and the whole weight of their worry landing on me, which would then require me to manage their worry, which is not what I need. I am tired of managing things. I am tired of being the one who holds it together. I have not said it, so it lives inside me, in the particular way that things you cannot say live inside you, which is quietly and completely and with a permanence that spoken things never quite achieve.
The fear is this. That if I did not show up one day, the absence would take longer to be noticed than it should. That the people in this city would eventually realise, after a meeting I missed or an email I did not reply to, that something was wrong. But the people at home, the ones whose voices I grew up hearing, whose faces I still see when I close my eyes on difficult nights, the ones I came from and still belong to in the deep way that has nothing to do with geography, those people would not notice at all. Not because they do not love me. I believe they love me. But because the way they love me has slowly, over the years, become indistinguishable from the way they need me. And need does not notice absence the way love does. Need simply waits, and then calls again when the need returns.
I know the exact moment I started to understand this. It was not dramatic. It was a Tuesday afternoon in November, grey the way only a northern winter can be grey, a grey that is less a colour than an absence of light, and my phone rang and it was my mother and my heart lifted the way it always does when my mother calls, that involuntary lift that I will never lose no matter how many years pass or how many grey Novembers accumulate, and before I had finished saying hello she had moved past the greeting into the reason for the call, which was money, which it usually was, and the conversation lasted eleven minutes and at the end of it I transferred what was asked for and sat for a long time after, not crying, not angry, simply sitting with the specific feeling of a hunger that had just been confirmed rather than fed.
I had wanted something from that call that the call was not designed to give. I could not have named it precisely in the moment but I know what it was now. I had wanted my mother to ask how I was. Not how things were, not whether I was managing, but how I was, the interior me, the one that does not show up in the amount transferred or the timelines met or the obligations honoured. I had wanted her to be curious about who her daughter was becoming in this foreign city, in this foreign life, in the particular aloneness of a woman who left everything familiar and is building herself from scratch in a place where nobody remembers who she used to be.
My mother did not ask. My mother never asks. Not because she is a bad mother. She is not a bad mother. She is a woman who was raised in a particular way, in a particular time, in a particular understanding of what it means to love someone, which is to ensure their survival, to fight for their futures, to do everything in your power to get them to a place where they will not struggle the way she struggled, and then, once they are there, to trust that they are fine because fine is what you fought for and fine is what they appear to be and appearing fine was supposed to be enough.
It is not enough. I know this now in a way I did not know before I left. When I lived at home, the dailiness of it covered over the gap. You do not notice what is missing from a relationship when you are inside it every day, when the texture of proximity substitutes for the texture of being known. I did not know, until I was far away and the calls came only when something was needed, that I had never quite felt seen by the people who loved me most. That the seeing had always been conditional. That I was most visible to them as a function, as a resource, as the one who made it, as evidence that the sacrifice was worth it, and least visible as the specific, complicated, frightened, hopeful, exhausted woman I actually am.
I do not tell them this. How would I begin? You have made me feel invisible for years and I have transferred money while feeling it and I do not know how to ask you to see me without it sounding like an accusation, and it is not an accusation, it is a need, the most basic human need there is, to be known by the people you come from, to matter to them not only for what you produce but for who you are. I do not know how to say any of that. So I answer the calls. I transfer what is needed. I say I am fine when they ask, on the occasions when they ask, and then I hang up and sit with the grey November light and the fear that lives underneath all of it.
The fear is not about death. I want to be precise about this because I have thought about it carefully. It is not a fear that something will happen to me. It is something more abstract and more devastating than that. It is the fear that I am already disappearing, slowly, in the way that people disappear when no one is holding their image in mind, when no one is tracking the changes, when no one knows that I cut my hair last month or that I have been reading a particular author who is rearranging the way I think about everything or that I cried for an hour last Wednesday for a reason I could not fully articulate but that had something to do with the accumulation of Wednesdays exactly like it.
No one knows these things. I have not told anyone and no one has asked and so the details of my interior life are accumulating unseen, the way things accumulate in a room no one enters, and I wonder sometimes what it would mean to be truly known by another person, the way I imagine people are known when they have a history with someone long enough and intimate enough that the knowing goes all the way down. I wonder if I left that possibility behind when I left. If the particular kind of being known that I am hungry for requires a shared past, a common language, a set of memories that belong to both people, and whether all of that is on the other side of a distance I chose and cannot now unchoose.
What I do not let myself think too often, because thinking it too directly is more than I can manage on an ordinary Tuesday, is that the people who could have given me that knowing have outsourced their relationship with me to my usefulness. That I have become, in the economy of my family’s love, a remittance. Reliable, necessary, appreciated in the abstract, unremarkable in the specific. They do not know who I am becoming because they have not needed to know. The account balance tells them what they need to know. I am doing well. I am fine. I am the one who made it.
I made it. I want to sit with the full strangeness of that phrase for a moment because I think it is at the heart of everything. I made it means I arrived somewhere. It implies a destination, a completion, a state of having-arrived that is stable and permanent and requires no further attention. I made it means the story is over, or at least the part of the story that requires other people’s attention is over, and what remains is simply the ongoing fact of my having made it, which generates money and pride but not, it turns out, the particular curiosity that would make someone ask how I am on a Tuesday afternoon in November for no reason other than wanting to know.
I walk to the shop on the corner sometimes at the end of the day and the man who runs it knows my order and sometimes we talk about nothing, about the weather, about a football match, about something he read in the news, and I am aware, in those moments, of something that might be the closest thing I have to being known in this city. He knows I take oat milk. He knows I come in on Fridays later than other days. He knows I like the dark chocolate with sea salt and that I will always say I am not going to get it and then get it anyway. This is not knowing. I am aware that this is not knowing. But it is something. It is a small, consistent, reliable something in a life that sometimes feels like it is made entirely of impermanence and distance and the low hum of a hunger I cannot name to anyone, including myself, on most days.
I am not looking for pity. I want to say that clearly because I know how this sounds and pity is not what I need and would not help me even if it were offered. What I need is something that pity cannot give, which is to be seen, specifically and completely, by someone who knows where I came from and chooses to be curious about where I am going. I need a phone call that begins with how are you and means it, that has time built into it for the real answer, that is not going anywhere until it has heard something true. I need someone from home to be interested in me the way I am interested in myself on my best days, which is with a kind of generous, patient, unfrightened attention that does not need me to be fine and does not need me to have made it and does not need anything from me at all except my honest company.
I do not know if that call is coming. I do not know if the people I love most have the language for it, or the habit of it, or the understanding that I need it. I suspect they do not know I am hungry because I have never shown them the hunger, because showing it felt like asking for something I was not sure I deserved, because the role I play in my family does not have hunger written into it anywhere. The role has competence and reliability and money and the ability to sort things from a distance. It does not have need. I wrote need out of the role a long time ago because need felt like weakness and weakness felt like a threat to the only version of myself that the people I love seem to be able to hold.
So I hold the fear instead. The fear that no one would notice. The fear that I am already, slowly, becoming someone who happened, who was here, who sent money on time and showed up when required and was fine, always fine, right up until the moment I wasn’t, and that even that moment would be processed primarily as an inconvenience, as a disruption to the arrangements, before it became a grief.
It is late now. The city outside my window is doing what cities do at this hour, which is continuing without me, indifferent and luminous and full of people who are each carrying something like this, though I do not know that, cannot know that, because the carrying is always done alone and in private and without the language that would let one person recognise it in another. I will sleep soon. Tomorrow I will be fine. I am always fine. I have made it.
I just wish, on nights like this, that making it felt less like disappearing.
Do you have something you need to say?
If something you have lived through needs to be written down and you cannot write it under your own name, write it to us. We will hold it carefully. We will share it anonymously, exactly as you send it, for every woman who needs to read it and know she is not alone.
Write to us at sema@mwanamkejasiri.co.ke